Skip to content
Bad Provenance

BP-2026.003.1

Busby Stoop Chair

Claim
5 of 5
Irreversible harm to the body, to a life, or to its continuation.
Evidence
2 of 5
One retelling, publication or sale listing.
Provenance
1 of 3
Described and identifiable, but its history is unrecorded.

These three figures are kept separate and are never combined into a single score. How grave the claim is, what it rests on, and whether the object can be traced are different questions. How the register reads them.

Asserted

Accounts attributed to a source. The register does not adopt them.

That it caused a death in the household. Thomas Busby was hanged in 1702 for the murder of his father-in-law and business partner in a counterfeiting operation. He is said to have cursed his favourite chair on the way to the gallows, so that anyone who sits in it will die. Deaths attributed to the chair include airmen during the Second World War and, in the 1970s, several fatal road accidents.

  • C20

    accident or injury

  • C27

    death

  • E2

    a named individual attributed to it

    index v0.8: Named individual attributed

  • T8

    begins on an act

  • H9

    subject of a ritual or curse

    index v0.8: Subject of a ritual, curse or blessing

  • H11

    belonged to a named perpetrator

  • H21

    associated with a named legend or figure

  • X14

    bound to an act of the observer

reported by: since the 1940s, largely by people who cannot be identified

Recorded

Established by the register, or received with the object.

File

Register number
BP-2026.003.1
Entry type
Object entry
Opened
2026-09-16
Coded against
Claim Index v0.8

Object

Type
oak armchair
Materials
oak
Date
c.1840
Origin
North Yorkshire, England
Whereabouts
held by an institution, Thirsk

Custody

No custody record has been entered.

On what grounds

The holding institution's own display record, and local tradition. Reported since the 1940s, largely by people who cannot be identified. Evidence is capped at 2: the object's date is incompatible with the claimed event.

Counter-indications

What weighs against the claim. These are never subtracted from a figure; the lowest applicable ceiling is applied instead.

  • CI1

    absent from the earliest sources

  • CI13

    the object's date is incompatible with the claimed event

  • CI21

    reporters cannot be traced

A furniture historian examined the chair and found machine-turned spindles, where an eighteenth-century chair would have been turned on a pole lathe. He dated it to around 1840 — one hundred and thirty-eight years after the execution.

Register findings

  • MT18

    physically restrained or immobilised

  • MT22

    access restricted

  • MT26

    exhibited publicly

  • MT27

    object of organised visitation

The chair was given to the museum in 1978 on the condition that no one sit in it. It hangs from the ceiling, out of reach of visitors and of cleaning staff.

Back to the index